Crafting TTRPG Stickers: Stickermule vs. Stickybrand vs. DIY Options

January 11, 2024

Starting a tabletop role-playing game (TTRPG) business? Adding a personal touch to your gaming gear with custom TTRPG stickers featuring Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) designs is a fantastic way to make a mark. In this blog post, we'll guide you through three major options—Stickermule, Stickybrand, and DIY printing—to help you kickstart your TTRPG business. Whether you prioritize quality, affordability, or hands-on creativity, we've got you covered in the world of TTRPG sticker crafting.

Stickermule: Premium Quality and Service

Stickermule stands out for its top-quality stickers, fast shipping, and excellent customer service, based on my personal experience. The stickers boast vibrant colors and precise details that are perfect for your TTRPG business. With quick shipping and responsive customer service, Stickermule is a reliable choice for getting your D&D designs out promptly and flawlessly. I regularly seize the opportunity to grab their special deals, as they offer substantial discounts that occur frequently.

Pros of Stickermule:

Exceptional Quality: Stickermule is synonymous with high-quality stickers that bring your D&D designs to life with vivid colors and precise details.
Professional Finish: The premium finish of Stickermule stickers adds a polished touch to your TTRPG accessories, enhancing the overall aesthetic.
Prompt Customer Service: In the rare event of issues, Stickermule's responsive customer service ensures swift and satisfactory resolutions.

Cons of Stickermule:

Higher Price Point: The superior quality comes at a higher cost, making Stickermule a premium choice for those willing to invest in top-notch stickers.
Limited Budget-Friendly Options: Stickermule may not offer as many budget-friendly deals or discounts, potentially making it less accessible for those on a tight budget.

Use this link to receive a $10 store credit when you spend $10 or more on your first order.

Stickybrand: Affordable Customization

Stickybrand becomes an excellent choice when it comes to ordering larger quantities of stickers for your inventory, offering competitive prices while maintaining good quality. Keep in mind that the trade-off is a slightly longer shipping duration compared to Stickermule.

Pros of Stickybrand:

Budget-Friendly: Stickybrand's affordability makes it an attractive choice for TTRPG enthusiasts looking to print stickers.
Attractive Deals: Stickybrand frequently provides promotions and discounts, making it a cost-effective solution for those planning larger sticker orders. They often have coupons that you can use on top of the special bulk deals.
Decent Quality: While not at the same level as Stickermule, Stickybrand produces satisfactory quality stickers that meet the expectations of many customers.

Cons of Stickybrand:

Extended Production Time: Patience is required when opting for Stickybrand, as the platform may have a longer turnaround time compared to Stickermule.
Occasional Quality Control Issues: Some users have reported occasional quality control issues or misprints, requiring additional time for resolution. Personally, I've had stickers lost in the mail and some quality control issues but the customer service has also helped me with replacements free of charge.

Use this link to receive $5 off your first order when you spend $60 at Stickybrand.

DIY Printing

Embarking on DIY printing with a printer and a cutting machine is an excellent starting point. Although it involves a steep learning curve with the cutting machines and a higher initial investment, the advantage lies in the ability to print your stickers on demand, eliminating the need for waiting.

Once you've identified your best-selling stickers, utilizing the printing services mentioned earlier is likely a better long-term strategy. This way, you can efficiently print in bulk, optimizing your production process.

Pros of DIY Printing:

Full Creative Control: DIY printing allows you to oversee every aspect of the production process, from design to the final product.
Cost-Effective for Small Batches: Particularly advantageous for small-scale operations, DIY printing can be more cost-effective for limited quantities.
Quick Turnaround: With the right equipment, DIY printing enables a swift turnaround, ideal for meeting customer demands promptly.

Cons of DIY Printing:

Learning Curve: Operating a cutting machine and managing the intricacies of printing can have a learning curve, especially for those new to the process.
Limited Scale: While suitable for smaller batches, DIY printing may become time-consuming and less cost-effective as your business grows.

The top two cutting machines that DIY sticker makers buy are the Cricut and the Silhouette. Personally, we use a Cricut, and once we fine-tuned the settings and perfected our process, it cuts well. However, we've also received positive feedback about the Silhouette.

Finding Your Perfect Fit

Whether you're prioritizing quality, affordability, or a hands-on approach, each option—Stickermule, Stickybrand, and DIY printing—brings unique advantages to the table. Stickermule stands out for its premium quality and professional finish, ideal for those who prioritize top-notch aesthetics. Stickybrand caters to budget-conscious sticker makers seeking affordability without compromising too much on quality. DIY printing offers complete creative control, making it an attractive option for those who enjoy hands-on crafting.

Ultimately, the perfect fit for your TTRPG sticker crafting journey depends on your priorities and preferences. Whether you choose Stickermule for top-tier quality, Stickybrand for budget-friendly options, or DIY printing for hands-on creativity, each option opens exciting possibilities for starting a TTRPG art or creative business.

Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. If you purchase products through one of our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thanks for supporting MinvaRPG!